Set an approved range and ceiling first, make a specific offer based on market and internal pay, and answer counters with job-related reasons. Here are the scripts, levers and pay equity guardrails.
- Agree on the range, the target offer and the maximum with the hiring manager and finance before the first salary conversation.
- Base the range on current market data, such as the BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, plus what you pay people already in the role.
- Federal law requires equal pay for substantially equal work regardless of sex, and Title VII bars pay discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex and national origin, so every exception needs a job-related reason.
- Some states, including California, bar employers from asking about salary history; ask about expectations instead.
- When you can’t move base pay, a signing bonus, earlier review, extra time off or remote flexibility often closes the gap.
In this article
To negotiate salary with candidates, set an approved pay range and a firm ceiling before you talk numbers, make a specific opening offer based on market data and internal pay, and respond to counteroffers with job-related reasons rather than haggling. Decide in advance which non-salary items you can flex, apply the same rules to every candidate, and document why each final number was chosen.
Set the pay range and your limits before the offer
Most offer negotiations go wrong before they start, because the recruiter doesn’t know how far they can go. Write down four numbers for every role:
| Number | What it is | Who approves it |
|---|---|---|
| Range minimum | The lowest pay for someone who meets the basic requirements | Compensation or HR |
| Range midpoint | Market rate for a fully qualified person in the role | Compensation or HR |
| Target offer | What you plan to offer this candidate, based on their experience against the job requirements | Hiring manager and HR |
| Ceiling | The most you will pay this candidate, including any pre-approved flex | Finance or department head |
Worked example
Say the range for a staff accountant is $70,000 to $86,000, so the midpoint is $78,000. Your three current staff accountants earn $76,000, $80,000 and $82,000. Your finalist meets every requirement and has slightly less experience than the $80,000 employee.
- Target offer: $78,000, at the midpoint and in line with the peer group.
- Ceiling: $80,000. Going higher would pay a less experienced new hire more than current staff, which creates an internal equity problem.
- Compa-ratio check: salary divided by midpoint. $78,000 / $78,000 = 1.00; at the ceiling, $80,000 / $78,000 = 1.03.
- Flex if the candidate asks for $85,000: base up to $80,000, plus a one-time signing bonus approved in advance.
Tip: Know your walk-away point before the first conversation. If a candidate’s minimum is above your ceiling, it’s better to learn that in the phone screen than after three interview rounds.
Where to get market salary data
Use more than one source and note which ones you used for each role:
- Government data. The BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics program publishes annual wage estimates for about 830 occupations, nationally, by state and by metro and nonmetro area. As of October 2026, the latest release covers May 2025 and was published May 15, 2026. It lags the market, so treat it as a floor check rather than the final answer for fast-moving roles.
- Salary surveys and guides. Careerscape’s free Salary Guide covers 450+ roles. Industry associations and compensation survey vendors publish more detail.
- Your own data. Pay of current employees in the role, recent offers that were accepted or declined, and the reasons candidates gave.
- Posted ranges. Competitors’ job postings, which are more common now that several states require ranges.
Our guide to salary benchmarking methods explains how to blend these sources, and pay transparency laws by state covers where you must post a range.
Pay equity rules that shape every negotiation
Negotiation is where pay gaps often start: two people in the same job end up with different salaries because one pushed harder or had a higher previous salary. Federal law sets the guardrails.
- Equal Pay Act of 1963. Requires equal pay for men and women for equal work on jobs requiring equal skill, effort and responsibility under similar working conditions in the same establishment. Differences are allowed only when based on a seniority system, a merit system, a system that measures earnings by quantity or quality of production, or a factor other than sex. The EEOC explains that jobs don’t need to be identical, only substantially equal, and that job content, not job title, decides this.
- Title VII, ADEA and ADA. The EEOC notes that these laws prohibit pay discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age and disability.
- All pay counts. The EEOC lists salary, overtime, bonuses, stock options, profit sharing, vacation and holiday pay, and benefits as covered. A larger signing bonus for one candidate is part of the comparison.
- Salary history bans. Several states and cities restrict asking about pay history. California’s Labor Code 432.3, for example, bars employers from seeking an applicant’s salary history or relying on it to decide whether to hire or what to pay, unless the applicant volunteers it, and prior salary alone can’t justify a pay disparity based on sex, race or ethnicity.
Practical rule: ask “What are your salary expectations for this role?” instead of “What do you make now?”, and base offers on the job, the market and the candidate’s job-related qualifications.
This is general information, not legal advice. Check with employment counsel for your situation, since state and local rules vary.
How to make the salary offer
Call first, then follow up in writing the same day. A verbal offer lets you hear the candidate’s reaction and answer questions; the written offer prevents misunderstandings.
Verbal offer script
“Thanks for making time. Everyone you met was impressed, and we’d like to offer you the [Job title] role. The base salary is $[amount] a year, and you’d be eligible for [bonus/benefits summary]. Your start date would be [date], reporting to [manager]. I’ll send the written offer today. What questions do you have, and is there anything that would keep you from accepting?”
The last question matters. It surfaces objections early, while you can still address them.
What the written offer should include
- Job title, manager and work location or arrangement
- Base pay and pay frequency, and exempt or nonexempt status
- Bonus, commission or equity terms, if any
- Benefits summary and when they start
- Start date and any contingencies (background check, references)
- A response deadline
See our guide to offer letter essentials for a full template, and offer deadlines for how long to give candidates.

How to respond when a candidate negotiates
Expect a counter on most professional roles. Stay calm, ask what’s driving it, and answer with reasons.
| Candidate says | What to find out | Sample response |
|---|---|---|
| “I was hoping for something closer to $X.” | Is $X a need, a market comparison or another offer? | “Thanks for telling me. Can you share how you got to that number? I want to see what I can do within our range.” |
| “I have another offer at $X.” | The full package, not just base; their deadline | “I appreciate the transparency. Besides salary, what matters most to you in deciding? Let me see what flexibility we have and come back to you by [time].” |
| “My current employer may counteroffer.” | Why they want to leave | “That’s common. What made you start looking? If those reasons are still true after a raise, it’s worth thinking about.” |
| Ask above your ceiling | Whether non-salary items help | “Our range for this role tops out at $[ceiling], and we pay people in this role consistently. I can offer [signing bonus/review at six months/extra PTO]. Would that work?” |
A few rules keep this fair and fast:
- Don’t exceed the approved ceiling on the call. Say you’ll check and give a specific time to get back to them.
- Move once, with a reason. “Given your certification, we can go to $80,000” is better than splitting the difference several times.
- Apply the same flex rules to everyone. If you’d raise one candidate’s offer for a credential, do it for any candidate with that credential.
- Don’t penalize candidates who negotiate, and don’t reward the ones who push hardest with pay their peers can’t get.
If a current employer counters, our counteroffer strategy guide covers how to respond.
Negotiation levers beyond base salary
| Lever | Cost to you | When it helps |
|---|---|---|
| Signing bonus | One-time; doesn’t raise future pay costs | Candidate is leaving a bonus or needs to bridge a gap |
| Earlier pay review (for example, at six months) | Low now, possible raise later | Candidate is slightly below range on experience |
| Extra paid time off | Moderate | Candidate would lose accrued vacation by leaving |
| Remote or flexible schedule | Often low | Long commute or caregiving needs |
| Start date | Low | Candidate wants to finish a project or take a break |
| Training or certification budget | Moderate; builds skills you need | Candidate is focused on growth |
| Relocation assistance | Moderate to high | Candidate is moving for the job; see our guide to relocation assistance |
Remember that bonuses and benefits count as pay under equal pay law, so the same consistency rules apply to these levers.
Document every offer decision
Keep a short record for each offer. It protects you if pay is ever questioned and makes future offers faster.
- The approved range, target and ceiling, with the date and approver
- Market sources used and their dates
- Current employees’ pay in the same role (internal equity check)
- Initial offer, any counter, and final agreed terms
- The job-related reason for any amount above the target (experience, certification, skills)
- Whether the candidate accepted, and if they declined, why
Tracking accepted and declined offers over time also shows whether your ranges are falling behind the market. Our article on offer acceptance rate explains how to measure it.
How Careerscape can help
Careerscape is a U.S. staffing and recruiting firm. Our free Salary Guide covers 450+ roles, and on direct hire searches our recruiters can help you set a competitive range and manage the offer conversation with your finalist.
Frequently asked questions
Should employers make the first salary offer?
Usually, yes. A specific first number based on your range and market data anchors the conversation and saves time. Many states now require pay ranges in postings, so candidates often know your range anyway. Ask about the candidate’s expectations early in the process, so you don’t reach the offer stage with a gap you can’t close.
How much room should you leave to negotiate?
Leave enough to move once without breaking internal equity. For many roles that means offering at or near your target and keeping a small, pre-approved amount between the target and the ceiling, plus a non-salary lever such as a signing bonus. Offering far below what you’d pay invites distrust and longer negotiations.
Can I ask a candidate how much they make now?
It depends on where you hire. Several states and cities restrict salary history questions; California, for example, bars employers from seeking an applicant’s salary history. Asking about salary expectations is a safer approach everywhere, and basing pay on the job and the market keeps your offers consistent.
What if a candidate asks for more than the top of the range?
Explain that the range reflects the role’s market value and what current employees are paid, then offer what you can flex: a signing bonus, an earlier pay review, more time off or schedule flexibility. If the gap is still too large, it’s fine to part ways. Raising the range for one person can create pay equity problems with your current team.
Is it legal to pay two people in the same job differently?
Yes, if the difference rests on legitimate, job-related factors. Under the Equal Pay Act, differences are permitted when based on a seniority system, a merit system, a system measuring quantity or quality of production, or a factor other than sex. Document the reason each time, and apply it consistently across candidates.
- U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission: Equal Pay/Compensation Discrimination
- U.S. EEOC: The Equal Pay Act of 1963 (29 U.S.C. 206(d))
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics: Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics
- State of California: California pay equity resources for employers (Labor Code 432.3)