Marketing & Creative · SEO hiring guide
Most SEO hires go wrong before the first interview, because the posting asks one person to fix site code, write content and win local rankings at once. Careerscape's marketing recruiters are a remote team covering the whole country, and they specialize in this field, so a search starts by naming which of those problems you need solved.
Search in 2026
Google's Search Status Dashboard lists two broad core updates so far in 2026, starting March 27 and May 21 and each rolling out for about 12 days, plus four spam updates, the most recent starting September 24. Ranking swings after updates like these are routine. A candidate who can explain a traffic drop with Search Console data, instead of a theory, is worth more than one who promises a quick recovery.
AI answers changed the results page more than the fundamentals. Google's own documentation says there are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, and that no new machine-readable files or markup are needed. A page has to be indexed and eligible to show a snippet. Clicks from these features are counted in the Search Console Performance report under the Web search type, so they are not missing from your data.
The controls still matter. Google points site owners to robots.txt for crawling; to nosnippet, data-nosnippet, max-snippet and noindex for what shows in Search; and to Google-Extended for limiting use in some of its other AI systems. Your hire should be able to tell you which of these your site uses and why, because one wrong directive can quietly pull pages out of results.
Pick the specialty
If you are asking whether to hire a technical SEO specialist, the first row is the test. O*NET lists SEO consultant and SEO strategist among the reported titles for search marketing strategists, and the tasks range from optimizing site assets to analyzing search patterns. In practice those tasks split into distinct jobs.
| Specialty | Hire it when | Works in | Screen for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Technical SEO | Pages are not being indexed, you are migrating or replatforming, or the site is large or built on JavaScript | Search Console, site crawlers, server logs, robots.txt, XML sitemaps, structured data | Can read a crawl and a log file and turn them into a ticket a developer can ship |
| Content and on-page SEO | You publish often and need briefs, internal links and refreshes of pages that slipped | Keyword research tools, your CMS (often WordPress), Google Analytics | Can tie a brief to a search intent and show a page they improved, with before and after data |
| Local SEO | You have physical locations or service areas | Google Business Profile, location pages, review responses | Knows the FTC's 2024 rule bans fake reviews, paying only for positive ones and threatening reviewers |
| Ecommerce SEO | Category and product pages carry revenue | Filtered category pages, product structured data, platform templates | Can control filtered and duplicate URLs without dropping products from the index |
| SEO generalist | You are a small team that needs the basics covered and an agency managed | All of the above at a working level | Knows where their skills stop and when to bring in a specialist |
Smaller teams often hire a generalist full time and bring in technical help on contract for a migration or a large audit. Source: O*NET OnLine, 13-1161.01 Search Marketing Strategists (titles, tasks, tools).
Posting draft
Edit the responsibilities to match the specialty you picked above. Cut anything the person will not actually own.
We are hiring an SEO specialist to grow qualified organic traffic to our website. You will find and fix technical issues, shape content around what our customers search for, and report results in plain language to the marketing team and leadership.
Interview
Give candidates a page or a short crawl export from your own site before the interview. The best questions are about their reasoning, not their vocabulary.
Listen for: Starts with Search Console: which pages, which queries, which dates. Separates seasonality and tracking problems from ranking loss before proposing any fix.
Listen for: Prioritizes by impact and effort, ties changes to the searcher's intent, and names what they would measure afterward.
Listen for: A specific story with redirects, indexing or lost pages, what they caught late and what they now check first.
Listen for: Knows Google says there are no special requirements for AI features, and is wary of any guarantee about rankings or placement.
Listen for: Talks about leads, revenue or cost per acquisition from organic search, not just rankings and sessions.
What it costs
BLS has no SEO occupation. It counts SEO specialists as marketing specialists, a group of 952,700 jobs nationally that also includes market research analysts, so the percentiles below cover a broader group than SEO alone.
Middle half of all workers (25th to 75th percentile)
A specialist who runs SEO for one site usually belongs near the national median. Technical leads who own migrations, log analysis and very large sites compete for offers in the upper quartile and above. The Salary Guide page gives role-specific figures. Annual pay, all U.S. employers, BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (May 2025), occupation: Market Research Analysts and Marketing Specialists. BLS does not publish this title separately; the figures are for market research analysts and marketing specialists, the closest BLS occupation, which can include other job titles. Pay by level and city: SEO Specialist salary guide.
Where to look
SEO work is usually done remotely, so this table matters most when you set a pay band for a candidate who lives in a high-cost metro. Concentration compares each metro's share of jobs in this group with the national share.
| Market | Jobs | Median pay · vs. U.S. | Concentration |
|---|---|---|---|
| New York City | 79,290 | $100,520+28% | 1.44 |
| Los Angeles | 39,390 | $82,990+5% | 1.09 |
| Boston | 32,310 | $102,390+30% | 2.07 |
| Chicago | 30,970 | $80,400+2% | 1.19 |
| San Francisco | 24,120 | $123,250+56% | 1.76 |
| Washington, DC | 21,090 | $87,160+11% | 1.16 |
| Dallas | 20,900 | $75,240−4% | 0.89 |
| Atlanta | 19,920 | $79,030±0% | 1.19 |
| Seattle | 18,030 | $102,170+30% | 1.49 |
| Philadelphia | 17,600 | $79,420+1% | 1.05 |
| Denver | 17,000 | $99,040+26% | 1.83 |
| Minneapolis | 16,760 | $97,910+24% | 1.48 |
| Houston | 14,480 | $67,370−14% | 0.76 |
| Phoenix | 12,220 | $74,590−5% | 0.89 |
| Detroit | 11,710 | $77,100−2% | 1.06 |
| Charlotte | 9,500 | $82,930+5% | 1.21 |
| Tampa | 8,420 | $75,210−5% | 1.01 |
| Austin | 8,270 | $80,460+2% | 1.11 |
| Portland | 8,130 | $85,350+8% | 1.16 |
| Raleigh-Durham | 6,470 | $78,980±0% | 1.50 |
| Baltimore | 5,920 | $74,620−5% | 0.75 |
| Nashville | 5,510 | $77,240−2% | 0.87 |
| Pittsburgh | 4,940 | $63,190−20% | 0.77 |
| Providence | 4,080 | $83,960+7% | 0.99 |
| Hartford | 3,080 | $78,220−1% | 0.89 |
| Buffalo | 2,520 | $75,990−4% | 0.81 |
| Albany | 2,160 | $76,140−3% | 0.83 |
| Miami | — | $78,990±0% | — |
| San Diego | — | $79,440+1% | — |
San Francisco has the highest local median for the group ($123,250), followed by Boston ($102,390), Seattle ($102,170) and New York ($100,520). Pittsburgh ($63,190) and Houston ($67,370) are the lowest, and both have below-average concentration. Boston has the densest pool relative to its size, at 2.07 times the national share, then Denver (1.83) and San Francisco (1.76). BLS publishes no job count for Miami or San Diego in this occupation. All figures are May 2025 estimates. Market Research Analysts and Marketing Specialists, by metro area, sorted by jobs. BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025; U.S. median $78,760. Concentration is the BLS location quotient: above 1.0 means the job is a bigger share of local employment than nationally.
Avoid these
Most of these come from treating SEO as one skill instead of several.
Ask candidates what business result their work moved. A list of keywords they ranked for says little about leads or sales.
No one controls Google's rankings. Treat a guaranteed position, or a guaranteed spot in AI answers, as a reason to end the conversation.
A technical SEO needs someone to ship fixes. If engineering time is not available, hire for content and on-page work, or budget developer hours first.
Since October 21, 2024, an FTC rule has prohibited fake reviews, incentives that depend on a positive review, and threats or intimidation to get negative reviews removed. Make sure a local SEO hire knows where the line is.
Traffic charts are easy to crop. Ask for the site, the dates and what else changed at the time, then check a reference.
Request talent
Describe the site, the specialty and the arrangement you want, and a recruiter who works on marketing roles will follow up.
Looking for a job instead? Submit your resume or browse open jobs.
FAQ
Hire a technical specialist when the problem is the site itself: pages not indexed, a migration coming, or a large ecommerce or JavaScript build. Hire a generalist when you need steady content and on-page work and someone to manage outside help. Many small teams hire a generalist and bring in a technical SEO on contract for audits and migrations.
An in-house specialist knows your product, sits with your developers and writers, and can act on findings the same week. An agency gives you breadth and specialist tools. A common setup is one in-house owner who sets priorities and manages a smaller agency or contractor for specialist work. If you hire in-house, make sure the person will have time and authority to get fixes shipped.
There is no license for SEO, and BLS describes certification in this occupation group as voluntary. Google's Skillshop offers free foundational certifications for products such as Google Ads and Google Analytics, and these show familiarity with the tools, not SEO judgment. A candidate's own work, with the site, dates and results, tells you far more than any certificate.
Yes, and it is one of the best uses of contract SEO. A migration has a clear start and end: redirect mapping, pre-launch checks, launch monitoring and cleanup. Look for someone who has run a migration of similar size and platform. If the contractor works out, a contract-to-hire arrangement lets you keep them for ongoing work.
Ask how they build links and how they produce content at scale. Be cautious about paid link schemes, mass-produced pages written mainly to rank, or buying expired domains to redirect their authority. Google's spam policies name all three, and the consequences fall on your site, not the consultant's. A careful candidate will describe what they refuse to do.
Job seekers never pay us a fee, and an employed candidate's search stays private. Browse open jobs or send your resume.
How can we help?
We got it!
A recruiter will reach out shortly.
Application Submitted!
Thank you for applying. We'll review your application and get back to you soon.